Along with Buffy, we began to realize that he couldn't use other LUSH products as well. Many of their products contain nuts and/or corn. But I've recently gotten in touch with LUSH again after many year, and a lovely PR rep provided me with some recommendations. We've been playing around with them, seeing if my husband's skin would react - and I've been having a lot of LUSH fun again. Here's what we've found:

My Experience - The awesomeness about this product comes from the fact that the exfoliation work is being done by oats, not almonds. It also smells heavenly (but I'm a sucker for yummy scents). To me it smells of milk, and oats, and honey - and I dig that. After a few days of living in my bathroom my bathroom smells HEAVENLY!!! Porridge Soap doesn't lather much - but my skin feels so good after using it. It's probably one of the most moisturizing bars I've tried in the shower.
My Husband' Experience - He approves. It didn't make him break out or get itchy. No allergy or hypersensitivity here!
Overall - I found a new must have! This is possibly the Buffy substitute I was looking for (though there really is no replacing Buffy).

My Experience - For me the lavender comes through loud and clear on this bar! It fits easily in my hand and quickly heats up to spread wonderful massage oil over the skin. A little goes a very long way. I was able to give my husband a nice back massage with it, using just a bit. The only thing I don't like about massage bars is that unlike oils in bottles I have to put it back in it's package. I may have to purchase a suitable "massage bar holder".
My Husband's Experience - Well I know he liked the massage.
Overall - I'd recommend this one for anyone who likes a relaxing lavender massage. The bar will probably be around for a long while.

My Experience - Ok, so I tried to use this one as a post-shower lotion. It didn't quite melt as quickly as Therapy. Once it does start to melt, then it's fine. I also don't like the smell very much. Not that it's obnoxious - the scent is slightly herbal. So if you like that you might like Peace.
My Husband's Experience - I'm making him stick with Therapy right now. So down the road maybe he'll try it.
Overall - Up to you. For this I'd go based on choice and cost - it is over $3 more expensive, and I don't know that it's worth it. But go on the website, read the story and watch the video. It's nice.

My Experience - This is billed as a body lotion on LUSH's site, but I have mainly been using it as a lip balm. I tried it on my body and it was a bit too greasy for that. It looks and feels almost identical to Vaseline (perhaps a slight tiny bit gritty in comparison). Think about what you use that for and you might have a petroleum jelly substitute in Ultrabalm if you're been looking for one. I think it is fantastic on knees, elbows, heels - anything that needs super moisture that won't be touching any cellphones, keyboards, or books any time soon. However be forewarned - it has sort of burn woodsy smell.
My Husband's Experience - I didn't let him at this one. Once I find a lip balm I like, it's mine.
Overall - Good product, but EXPENSIVE compared to similar products.
Anyway, I hope this information helps someone out there. The PR rep who gave me the "non-nut or corn" recommendations also recommended Dream Cream which I did not purchase due to price but feel free to look that up as well.